| Monash home | About Monash | Faculties | Campuses | Contact Monash |
| Staff directory | A-Z index | Site map |
|
|
Academic Board Meeting 3-2009MINUTESMeeting No 3/2009 of the Academic Board was held on Wednesday 17 June 2009 from 3:30pm-5:30pm, in the Council Chambers, First floor, Building 3A, Clayton campus. Rhonda Hinds There were present: Apologies were received from: Special Leave: Observers: Overseas Observers: In attendance: AGENDA A PRELIMINARY AND FORMAL BUSINESS 1 WELCOME Professor Jayne Godfrey welcomed members and observers to the meeting, including those attending the meeting by teleconference from the South African, Sunway and Gippsland campuses. 2 ARRANGEMENT OF AGENDA 2.1 Alterations to the Agenda and Starring of Items
2.2 Approval of Non-Starred Items The recommendations of the Steering Committee were adopted without discussion for all items other than those starred. C 2.3 Confidential Items 3 MINUTES 3.1 Minutes of Academic Board Meeting 2/2009 The Minutes of Meeting 2/2009, held on Wednesday, 22 April 2009, were confirmed. 3.2 Business arising from the Minutes 3.2.1 Schedule of Action Items Academic Board received and noted the updated Schedule of Action Items. For information: Ms R Hinds 3.2.2 Review of PhD English language proficiency requirements Professor Rod Devenish introduced the Report of the Review of PhD English Language Proficiency Requirements, noting that the review had been undertaken pursuant to the request of the Board. Academic Board:
For information: Professors M King, R Devenish 3.2.3 Student membership of faculty boards Members had before them the result of a survey on student representation on faculty boards, undertaken in response to the President’s request for confirmation of faculty board student membership requirements. Thanking the Board for its response, Ms Buckley encouraged all faculty boards to move to a process of electing their student representatives, and encouraged the filling of any casual vacancies at the earliest opportunity. During discussion, some members commented that it would be desirable for participation by offshore students to be increased. The President indicated that the Board would investigate processes that might facilitate such participation. Academic Board received and noted the survey of student representation on faculty boards. For information: Ms R Hinds, Ms G Buckley 3.2.4 Collaboration Services Initiative Academic Board noted the Report from the Chief Information Officer on the status of the Collaboration Services Initiative. For information: Mr A McMeekin, Dr C Jevons 4 PRESIDENT’S BUSINESS 4.1 President’s Report Professor Godfrey addressed Academic Board on a range of issues, including:
Academic Board received and noted the President’s Report. For information: Professors J Godfrey, R Larkins, A Freiberg 4.2 Vice-Chancellor Farewell On behalf of Academic Board, Professor Godfrey paid tribute to the retiring Vice-Chancellor, Professor Larkins, on his outstanding service to Monash University. Amongst many highlights of his leadership, she made particular mention of his having united Monash under a common academic banner, and in pursuit of a vision for the University to which all members of the Monash community could aspire. Professor Godfrey reminded members of the range of significant education, research and international initiatives led or supported by Professor Larkins and emphasised the Board’s appreciation of his support for a strong and independent Academic Board. Echoing Professor Godfrey’s comments, Professor Tony Luff (the longest-serving member of Academic Board), spoke of his regard for Professor Larkins as an outstanding Vice-Chancellor, able to mentor and support individual staff members whilst steering Monash to achievement of its strategic objectives. Student members of the Board joined in expressing their thanks for Professor Larkins’ support of the student population and in wishing him well for the future. Responding thereto, Professor Larkins paid tribute to his colleagues, including the Monash senior leadership, indicating also that he considered it a great privilege to be witness to the energy, enterprise and calibre of Australia’s future leaders. He briefly touched on some of the highlights of his term of office, and observed that Monash’s multi-campus structure and significant international footprint left it well placed to successfully engage at various levels, with the potential to become one of the world’s great universities. He reiterated his commitment to the Academic Board as an independent body and encouraged participation from members of the Monash community in its leadership. Academic Board marked, with acclamation, the service to Monash of the retiring Vice-Chancellor, Professor Richard Larkins AO. For information: Professors R Larkins J Godfrey, A Luff, Ms L O’Dwyer 5 VICE-CHANCELLOR’S BUSINESS 5.1 Vice-Chancellor’s Report Professor Richard Larkins reported to the Board on a range of issues, including:
Academic Board received and noted the Vice-Chancellor’s report. For information: Professor R Larkins 5.2 Award of Honorary Degrees Professor Larkins reported on the award of honorary degrees during Semester 1/2009, to Dr June Hearn, Dr Marcus Besen, Dr Eva Besen, Professor Barbara Cannon, and Dr Jeremy Ellis. Academic Board received and noted the report of the award of honorary degrees. 5.3 Indirect Costs of University Research Academic Board received and noted the letter from the Department of Innovation, Industry, Science and Research providing a progress report on the project to examine the indirect costs of university research and inviting participation in a related survey to be carried out on behalf of the Department by the Allen Consulting Group. 6 QUESTIONS ON NOTICE There were no questions on notice. B DIRECTION OF ACADEMIC AFFAIRS 7 FEDERAL BUDGET Members had before them a briefing paper from the Office of the Pro Vice-Chancellor (Planning and Quality) on the implications for the higher education sector of the 2009-2010 Federal Budget. Responding to a member query regarding the Monash approach to EIF submissions, the Vice-Chancellor informed the Board that efforts were made to ensure applications were consistent with Monash’s strategic priorities. Therefore, the criteria for the Sustainability/Clean Energy funding pool would, once released, be examined to determine alignment with Monash’s priorities, though it was anticipated that Monash was well-placed to feature strongly in this category. Discussion also ranged around the impact of demand-driven funding and increased low SES participation, in particular, whether Monash would wish to expand beyond its current capacity. Members were advised that not only was the desire for expansion unlikely to be consistent across campuses, but that rather than increasing the size of the student body, it might be more useful to re-examine the student mix. Academic Board received and noted the briefing paper from the Office of the Pro Vice-Chancellor (Planning and Quality) on the implications for the higher education sector of the 2009-2010 Federal Budget. For information: Professors R Larkins, A Shoemaker, M Evans, Mr D Watson 8 COOPERATIVE RESEARCH CENTRES Academic Board received and noted the update on Monash’s potential involvement in six Cooperative Research Centres (CRCs), currently applying for financial support through the Round 11 CRC program. For information: Professor E Cornish C SUPERVISION OF ACADEMIC AFFAIRS 9 PRESENTATION - DAMOCLES Academic Board received and noted a demonstration of Damocles, the plagiarism detection application developed by Dr David Squire (Faculty of Information Technology). Emphasis during the presentation was made not only of its detection capacity for punitive purposes, but also on its use as an educative tool. Members were also advised that there were significant advantages over other plagiarism detection software, especially insofar as students were not required to assign copyright over their work upon submission for checking. Members expressed strong support for further development of Damocles as an enterprise-wide system and were advised that Dr Squire was currently in discussion with the Director Commercialisation regarding scaling up to an enterprise-wide application. A further report for the Board’s August meeting was foreshadowed. Academic Board received and noted Dr Squire’s presentation. For information: Dr D Squire, Professor A Shoemaker 10 ACADEMIC PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW 10.1 Faculty of Engineering – Dual Award PhD Programs Academic Board:
For information: Professor M King, Ms M Cook, Ms S Lipscombe 10.2 Faculty of Information Technology – Dual Award PhD Programs Academic Board:
For information: Professor M King, Ms M Cook, Ms S Gleeson 11 UNIVERSITY ACADEMIC STRUCTURE 11.1 Establishment of the Graduate School of Jewish Studies Members were advised that the proposal had not canvassed the library resourcing implications of establishing the Graduate School of Jewish Studies at the Caulfield campus. In particular, whilst there was a good Jewish studies collection at the Clayton Library, there was currently no capacity to add a new collection to the Library at Caulfield. Following discussion, Academic Board:
For information: Professor R Frances, A/Prof M Baker, Ms C Harboe-Ree 12 MAINTENANCE OF ACADEMIC STANDARDS – AUQA 12.1 Preparations for AUQA Academic Board noted a briefing paper from the Office of Planning and Quality on preparations for the AUQA Audit. 12.2 Business Intelligence - Education Academic Board received and noted a pilot demonstration of the Business Intelligence (BI) - Education Phase, noting that the aim of the Business Intelligence Project was to provide high quality management information in a single repository with improved access and end user-driven analysis. Members observed that the Business Intelligence application offered a powerful and flexible tool for monitoring of quality and comparison of standards which was of particular importance in view of preparations for the AUQA audit. Academic Board received and noted the Business Intelligence – Education Phase demonstration. For information: Professor M Evans, Ms J Vero, Dr K Macrae, Ms M Dibben, Mr G Roughsedge 13 REPORTS FROM THE DEPUTY-VICE CHANCELLORS Professor Shoemaker reported on a range of issues related to the Education Portfolio, including:
Academic Board received and noted the report from Professor Shoemaker. For information: Professors A Shoemaker, N Thomson, A/Prof C Varsavsky, Dr L Bennett D GOVERNANCE 14 LEGISLATION 14.1 Amendment to Faculty Regulations Academic Board endorsed, for submission to Council, the proposal to make the Faculties Regulations (Amendment No.1 2009). For information: Ms J Wantrup 14.2 Amendment to Statute 6.2 - Exclusion for unsatisfactory progress or inability to progress and the Regulations pursuant to Statute 6.2 Academic Board endorsed, for submission to Council:
For information: Ms G Beecher, Mr M Fenaughty, Mr K Williamson 14.3 Amendment to Statute 6.1.5 - Examinations Academic Board endorsed, for submission to Council, the proposal to make Statute 6.1.5 – Assessment. For information: Ms J Wantrup, Assoc Prof C Varsavsky, Mr M Fenaughty 15 POLICY DEVELOPMENT AND REVIEW 15.1 Student Evaluation Policy and Procedures Academic Board:
For information: Dr K Macrae, Ms N Mitchell, Mr M Fenaughty, Mr K Williamson 15.2 Non-award Study Policy and Procedures Academic Board:
For information: Ms N Mitchell, Mr M Fenaughty, Mr K Williamson 15.3 Sessional Academic Support and Development Project Members noted that Education Committee had recommended amendment to the Monash Sessional Training Framework (Secretarial note: insertion of an additional dot point at sub-section 3.2 of the Framework, as follows: “Library resources and services.”) Academic Board:
http://www.odvce.monash.edu.au/projects/sessional/index.html For information: Dr L Bennett, Mr M Fenaughty, Mr K Williamson 15.4 Outside Studies Program (OSP) This item was deferred to the next meeting of Academic Board. 15.5 Report of the Assessment Policy Working Party Academic Board:
For information: A/Prof C Varsavsky, Ms N Mitchell, Mr M Fenaughty, Mr K Williamson 15.6 Unit Guide Policy and Procedures Subject to insertion of the phrase “or equivalent” immediately following “Unit Guide Template” in the Policy Statement, Academic Board:
For information: A/Prof J Hurst, Ms N Mitchell, Mr M Fenaughty, Mr K Williamson 15.7 Admission of Observers Policy and Procedures Academic Board approved the Admission of Observers to Council and Academic Board Meetings Policy and Procedures. For information: Mr A Calder, Mr D Secomb, Mr K Williamson 16 ACADEMIC BOARD MEMBERSHIP 16.1 Election of Academic Staff to Academic Board Academic Board received and noted the Declaration of the Poll in the election of Academic Staff to Academic Board. For information: Ms R Hinds, Mr M Fenaughty 16.2 Nomination of Heads of Academic Units to Academic Board Academic Board received and noted the reports of the nomination of Heads of Academic Units to Academic Board from the following faculties:
For information: Ms R Hinds 16.3 Election of Director of Research Institute/Centre to Academic Board Attached is the Returning Officer’s Declaration of the Poll. Academic Board received and noted the Declaration of the Poll in the election of one Director, Research Institute/Centre to Academic Board. For information: Professor P Bonnington, Ms R Hinds 16.4 Special Leave Academic Board granted special leave from attendance at meetings of the Board to the following member: Professor Chris Browne MN&HS Meeting 3/2009 For information: Professor C Browne 16.5 Election of Student Members to Academic Board Academic Board received and noted the Declaration of the Poll in the election of undergraduate student members to Academic Board (to commence 1 January 2010). For information: Mr M Fenaughty, Ms M Prior, Mr J Thomas 17 STANDING COMMITTEES OF ACADEMIC BOARD 17.1 Review of Steering Committee Members had before them proposals for review of the Terms of Reference and membership of Steering Committee and a process proposed for dealing with urgent business out of the Board’s normal meeting cycle. Academic Board noted that the review of Academic Board terms of reference and composition had been cascaded to reviews of the terms of reference and composition of standing committees, including Steering Committee. The Board also noted that the proposal for Steering Committee to deal with urgent items of business between regular meetings of the Board would better position the Board to respond to matters arising in a fast-paced academic and commercial environment. Academic Board approved:
For information: Professor B Canny, Ms R Hinds 17.2 Review of Education Committee Professor Shoemaker introduced the revised Terms of Reference and proposed membership of Education Committee. Academic Board:
For information: Professor A Shoemaker, Dr C Hewlett, Mr M Fenaughty 17.3 Proposal to establish an International Committee Members had before them the proposal to establish an International Committee of Academic Board, which had been endorsed by the Vice-Chancellor’s Group Meeting of 20 May 2009. The Board noted that the proposal for establishment of an International Committee of Academic Board would recognise the significance of the international aspects of Monash’s academic and research endeavours and would better enable the Board to discharge its responsibility to direct academic affairs and monitor and maintain academic standards. Academic Board approved:
For information: Professor S Fahey, Ms C Chatterton 17.4 Membership of the Exclusion Appeals Panel Academic Board approved the Deans’ nominations to membership of the Exclusion Appeals Committee Panel for the 2009-2010 term. For information: Mr K Williamson 17.5 Membership of the Board of the Faculty of Law Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to Council, the extension of the term of membership of Mr Mark Hayes on the Board of the Faculty of Law. For information: Professor A Freiberg, Ms J Beaton 18 REPORTS FROM STANDING COMMITTEES 18.1 Monash University Research Committee Meeting 2/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2009 of the Monash University Research Committee. For information: Ms M Soederberg 18.2 Honorary Degrees Committee Meeting 2/2008 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2008 of the Honorary Degrees Committee. For information: Mr B Corless 18.3 Research Graduate School Committee Meetings 3 and 4/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 3 and 4/2009 of the Research Graduate School Committee. For information: Ms M Cook 18.4 Education Committee Meetings 2 and 3/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 2 and 3/2009 of the Education Committee. For information: Mr M Fenaughty 19 FACULTY BOARD REPORTS 19.1 Faculty of Art & Design Meeting 1/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 1/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Art & Design. For information: Ms N Howard 19.2 Faculty of Information Technology Meeting 2/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Information Technology. For information: Ms H Spittle 19.3 Faculty of Business and Economics Meeting 2/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics. For information: Ms H Matich 19.4 Faculty of Science Meetings 1 and 2/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 1 and 2/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Science. For information: Ms G Key 19.5 Faculty of Engineering Meeting 2/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Engineering. For information: Mr R Smiley 19.6 Faculty of Law Meeting 1/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 1/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Law. For information: Ms J Beaton 19.7 Faculty of Education Meetings 1 and 2/2009 Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 1 and 2/2009 of the Board of the Faculty of Education. For information: Ms S Plowright E ITEMS OF OTHER BUSINESS 17 OTHER BUSINESS 18 NEXT MEETING – please note earlier commencement time The next meeting of the Academic Board for 2009 will be held on Wednesday 26 August 2009 in the Council Chambers, 1st floor, Building 3a, Clayton Campus commencing at 3.00 pm. |